What Facts Mean

A person can know more and see less.
Knowledge does not remain a collection of facts. It becomes structure. Relationships form between observations. Causes are assigned. Categories harden. Expectations develop about what follows from what. The structure makes an otherwise unmanageable world intelligible.
As knowledge accumulates, the structure becomes more capable. It explains more events with fewer unresolved questions. Familiar patterns become easier to recognize. New information finds an existing place. What began as a way of organizing reality becomes the means through which reality is encountered.
Mastery strengthens this process. A well-developed model contains more distinctions, more history, more mechanisms, and more explanations for apparent contradiction. Its holder can interpret events that would confuse someone with less knowledge. The same capacity also makes the model harder to displace.
Reality does not remain inside the conditions under which a model formed. Technologies change. Institutions change. Relationships between causes and consequences change. Mechanisms appear that resemble older ones while behaving differently. Eventually reality produces something the model did not anticipate.
The anomaly enters through the structure already in place.
An unexpected event becomes an exception. A new mechanism receives an established name. A contradictory result is attributed to unusual conditions. When contradictions accumulate, additional distinctions can preserve the original explanation. Greater knowledge supplies more material for doing this precisely, coherently, and indefinitely.
Nothing about the process requires dishonesty. The person can remain curious, informed, and attentive. New facts can be sought aggressively. Contrary evidence can be examined in detail. Arguments can become more sophisticated as the distance between expectation and reality grows.
The model can account for its own failures.
At that point, contradiction no longer threatens the structure. It becomes another phenomenon the structure explains. Evidence that might have forced revision is converted into evidence requiring interpretation. The model survives because every departure from it arrives already classified by it.
This is how perception can narrow while knowledge expands. The failure is not that facts disappear. More facts can produce more explanations, and more explanations can make the existing structure increasingly difficult to escape.
The world continues changing. The facts keep arriving. The model decides what they mean.


Discussion about this post